Grading The First ‘Perfect’ Coin

Remember when grading the first ‘perfect’ coin was considered shocking?
From the Memory Bank: Statue of Liberty commemorative gold $5 half eagle makes history

This article From the Memory Bank series was first published in the October 24, 2016 issue of Coin World available here.

Grading the Perfect 1986 Statue of Liberty Gold 5-Dollar Coins - Cash In Your Coins

The 1986 Statue of Liberty gold $5 series was the first documented to achieve perfection, with specimens graded MS-70 and Proof 70 in late June 1986. Images shown illustrate the grades, but are not the first coins to receive the top grade. Coin images courtesy of Heritage Auctions and eBay seller NJI Coins.

Question: What U.S. coin was first to be documented “perfect” and the first to be graded Mint State 70 and Proof 70? With literally millions of coins encased in plastic holders today bearing the grades MS-70 and Proof 70, some may question, “Why is this important or worth a mention?’’

Continue reading

American Eagle gold bullion coin

Did you ever almost wish something would go wrong?
Editor remembers flawless 1986 first-strike event for the American Eagle gold bullion coin

This article From the Memory Bank series was first published online September 9, 2016 on the Coin World website available here.

Where were you Monday, Sept. 8, 1986?

1986 American Eagle Gold Bullion Coin First Strike Ceremony

Mint Director Donna Pope, Secretary James A. Baker III, and Treasurer Katherine D. Ortega show the American Eagle $50 coins they struck Sept. 8, 1986, at the first-strike ceremony at the West Point Bullion Depository.
Coin World photo by Beth Deisher; coin image courtesy of

Carrying my camera bag stuffed with my SLR film camera, lens, flash equipment, ID and a few personal items, I boarded the 7:10 a.m. flight that day from Columbus, Ohio, to New York’s LaGuardia Airport. By 8:30 a.m. I was hailing a cab to David Ganz’s Manhattan law office, where I met David and Harvey Stack. David drove us to West Point, N.Y., to attend the ceremonial first-strike of the United States’ first $50 (1-ounce) American Eagle gold bullion coin.

We arrived shortly before 11 a.m. at the West Point Bullion Depository on the grounds of the West Point Military Academy.

Since I had attended the Oct. 18, 1985, first-strike ceremony for the Statue of Liberty gold $5 commemorative coin at West Point, I knew I had to register and pick up my press credentials. The U.S. Mint staff greeted me and provided a press kit. Just as I was about to step away, one of the staff members beckoned me to the side.

Continue reading

Availability of Commemoratives

A website visitor and blog reader contacted me recently with the following question:

Dear Beth Deisher, I am a reader of your memory bank columns in Coin World. Perhaps you can solve a situation that puzzles me.

I am a collector of early commemoratives. Why, when there is a limited mintage of some issues such as the Isabella Quarter, so many sellers seem to offer a number of these coins?
I’ve asked this question at coin shows and have never received a satisfactory answer. Thank you.


Here is my response to J.B.:

Continue reading

Grading revolution in 1986 changes hobby

Grading revolution in 1986 changes hobby with slabs, grade guarantee
PCGS founding has profound effect on coin collecting.

This article From the Memory Bank series was first published in the August 22, 2016 issue of Coin World available here.

Coin Grading in 1the 1980s

The Professional Coin Grading Service was founded in 1986 and changed the market. PCGS-certified and -graded coins, with an insert identifying a coin and its grade, were placed in sonically sealed holders that would gain the nickname “slabs.” Before that, ANACS issued photo certificates with coins. Images courtesy of PCGS and ANACS.

One milestone being celebrated this year stands above all others in terms of profound change to the U.S. coin market: launch of the Professional Coin Grading Service on Feb. 3, 1986.

Inconsistency in grading and whether to use words or numbers to describe the surface condition or “grade” of a coin dominated the headlines and opinion columns of Coin World and other publications in the first four years of the 1980s. During 1985 the decibels seemed to grow louder almost weekly, with most of the ire directed at ANACS.

ANACS — the then acknowled­ged leading third-party grading service by volume of coins graded — was operated as a separate division of the nonprofit American Numismatic Association, the largest coin collector organization.

Continue reading

Women in numismatics unite

Women in numismatics unite in 1991 to WIN: From the Memory Bank

Hobby organization marks 25 years in 2016
This article From the Memory Bank series was first published in Coin World available here.
Cash In Your Coins Women in Numismatics Founders

Two of the three founders of Women In Numismatics are Sondra Beymer, left, and Mary Sauvain. WIN celebrates its 25th anniversary this year. The club’s logo was designed by Elizabeth Jones, former chief sculptor-engraver for the U.S. Mint.
Coin World file photos.

Numismatic collectibles, both as a hobby and a business, has been and remains a predominately male domain, about 90 percent male and 10 percent female.

But that statistic does not begin to tell this story.

As the last decade of the 20th century dawned, it was evident that women were increasingly visible both in participation and leadership within the numismatic community in the United States.

Continue reading

Coin World Editor Testifies

Coin World Editor Testifies in Congress in 1988: From The Memory Bank

Hobby Leader Promoted Coin Redesign in Testimony
This article From the Memory Bank series was first published in Coin World available here.
Coin World Editor testifies

Coin World editor Beth Deisher testifies before Congress in 1988 regarding proposed coinage redesigns. Coin World file photo.

Only the United States Congress has the constitutional authority to order the U.S. Mint to create and strike a new U.S. coin, whether it is circulating or commemorative.

Thus advocates for new commemorative coins as well as for new designs on the nation’s circulating coinage plunged into the political arena during the 1980s with the belief they could prevail through the power of persuasion.

Continue reading